Pushback
Save the Records, Skip the Verdict: What Rep. Raskin's Signal Letters Leave Out
Federal records law matters, and agencies should follow it. But the law already allows outside messaging apps with a 20-day backup rule, and it was the Biden administration's own cyber agency that urged officials onto apps like Signal.
By LAUREN PIERCEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 20, 10:40 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Rep. Jamie Raskin, the top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, sent a batch of letters on Thursday warning federal agencies against using messaging apps such as Signal with messages set to disappear. He wrote that the practice violates the law and could undermine congressional oversight, The Hill reported.
The letters went to Justice Department components, the FBI and other agencies, and they were prompted by a screenshot showing the bureau's top lawyer messaging a Trump family associate on Signal, according to The Hill. Raskin wrote that the participants appear to have set the messages to delete after one week, and he asked the FBI to open an inquiry and recover any improperly deleted records under federal records law. He also wrote that unlawfully destroying federal records is a felony and said the FBI's general counsel appeared to have done so.
The FBI did not immediately respond to a request for comment, the Associated Press reported. Democrats, preparing to wield new investigative power after their midterm wins, have made clear that records preservation is one of their early concerns.
Let me be fair to the congressman. Federal records belong to the American people, and agencies should preserve them. If any official, of any party, destroyed records that the law requires be kept, that is a real problem. But Raskin's letters go further than the facts and the law support.
The Law Regulates the Record, Not the App
Start with the statute. Under 44 U.S.C. 2911, a federal employee may not create or send a record using a non-official messaging account unless the employee either copies an official account at the time or forwards a complete copy to an official account within 20 days. Violations can lead to discipline.
In other words, Congress already decided that officials may sometimes use outside apps, as long as the official record is captured. The question in any given case is whether the record was preserved, not whether someone opened Signal. A disappearing-message setting raises a fair question. It is not, by itself, proof of a crime. Declaring a felony before anyone has checked whether the messages were forwarded or archived puts the verdict ahead of the evidence.
It Was Biden's Cyber Agency That Recommended Signal
There is a reason so many officials use encrypted apps. On Dec. 18, 2024, during the Biden administration, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency told senior government and political officials to use only end-to-end encrypted communications and to adopt apps like Signal, after the Chinese Salt Typhoon hacks of American telecom networks, VOA reported.
That guidance was sound. Chinese intelligence had burrowed into the phone system. Telling officials to keep sensitive conversations off ordinary texts was a security decision, not a scheme. Any honest discussion of Signal in government has to start there.
One Standard for Everyone
Records law is at its best when it is applied evenly. In 2024, the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic examined Dr. David Morens, a senior adviser to Dr. Anthony Fauci, whose own emails showed he had moved official business to Gmail and deleted messages. The panel concluded that he violated federal records rules, and he was held to account in a public hearing. That scrutiny was the right response.
That is the standard conservatives should hold, and it is the standard Raskin should hold too: look at the facts, check whether the records were kept, and apply the same rules to a Fauci adviser and a Trump appointee alike. Preservation letters are a normal tool. Public accusations of felonies before the facts are in are not oversight. They are messaging.
What Comes Next
The administration has pushed back on the broader story line. The White House and the Pentagon have said disgruntled former employees were spreading false claims about officials' Signal use, according to the AP.
Under the statute, the practical next steps are straightforward. Agencies can confirm that their messaging policies require copying or forwarding within 20 days, archivists can check compliance, and if a record was lost, the law already lays out how to recover it, under the same records provision Raskin himself cites. That is how the system is supposed to work, quietly and by the rules.
Democrats will gain real investigative power in the new Congress. The country is better served if they use it the way the Constitution intends: to gather facts that inform legislation and hold every official to the same law, rather than to announce conclusions first and look for evidence later.
Sources
- The Hill: Jamie Raskin warns federal agencies against Signal use (link)
- ABC News: House Democrat probes agencies' use of messaging apps to discuss official business (link)
- MS NOW: Democrats have a big concern as they prepare to investigate the Trump administration (link)
- Cornell Legal Information Institute: 44 U.S. Code § 2911 - Disclosure requirement for official business conducted using non-official electronic messaging accounts (link)
- VOA: US cyber watchdog seeks switch to encrypted apps following Salt Typhoon hacks (link)
- House Committee on Oversight: Hearing Wrap Up: Dr. Fauci's Top Advisor Held Accountable for COVID-19 Federal Records Violations (link)
— 30 —


