‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Politics

Senate Republicans Hit Pause on Trump's $350 Billion Party-Line Pentagon Push and Try a Bipartisan Deal Before the Dec. 11 Deadline

Leaders are turning to talks with Democrats on a $1.1 trillion defense bill while keeping reconciliation on the table, as worries over Medicaid cuts and a Christmas shutdown weigh on the conference.

By DOUGLAS PARKStaff Correspondent · VIRGINIA · Nov 20, 11:31 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: The Pentagon building seen from the air at sunrise with the Potomac River and the Washington skyline beyond, the U.S. Capitol dome faint in the distance, an open federal budget ledger and a calculator on a desk in a…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Senate Republicans have put President Trump's request for a $350 billion party-line defense package on hold and will first try to negotiate a deal with Democrats, The Washington Post reported. The Post said Republicans cited the backlash from this month's midterm elections over the war with Iran.

Senate Majority Leader John Thune said the GOP would attempt to negotiate a deal to pass the spending package, according to the Post. Reuters reported that the conference decided to pursue bipartisan talks with Democrats on a $1.1 trillion defense appropriations bill that includes only $69 billion of the president's request, while keeping the party-line route available.

How We Got Here

The president asked Congress to fund the Pentagon through budget reconciliation, the special process that lets a bill pass the Senate with a simple majority and no filibuster. Before the pause, Thune had said Republicans would need to adopt a budget resolution by Thanksgiving to unlock the $350 billion that way, and he was weighing whether enough Republican senators supported it, The Hill reported.

Separately, Senate appropriators unveiled a roughly $1.1 trillion Pentagon spending bill that folds in some of the priorities Republicans had hoped to move through reconciliation, Breaking Defense reported. That bill is now the vehicle for talks with Democrats.

The Medicaid Problem

A big obstacle is what else would ride along. Thune and other Republican senators fear a revolt in their own ranks over Medicaid changes in the reconciliation package that are projected to cut Medicaid spending by as much as $1 trillion, The Hill reported.

That is a heavy lift for any majority, let alone one in its final weeks of control. Republicans who lost seats in the midterms, and those who will face voters in 2028, know that health care cuts written in a hurry rarely age well.

The Shutdown Clock

All of this runs into a hard deadline. The stopgap law funding the government expires on Dec. 11, and lawmakers must act by then or face a shutdown, Reuters reported. Democrats have warned that a party-line Pentagon push would jeopardize a broader deal to keep the government open, according to The Hill.

A Budget Hawk's Take

As someone who watches every dollar Washington spends, I see wisdom in the pause.

First, regular order is the constitutional way to fund the military. Article I gives Congress the power of the purse, and the appropriations process is where spending is supposed to be debated, amended and voted on in the open. A bipartisan defense bill is also more durable than a party-line package that the next majority can attack.

Second, the troops need certainty more than they need a political win. A shutdown at Christmas, with service members uncertain about pay and contracts frozen, would hurt the very readiness the $350 billion is meant to build.

Third, the country's fiscal problems are not going away. Pairing a large new defense package with roughly $1 trillion in Medicaid changes in a lame-duck session is not the careful, well-vetted reform that conservatives should want. If Medicaid needs fixing, and it does, that deserves its own debate.

Fourth, timing matters. A budget resolution would have to pass before Thanksgiving to keep the reconciliation path alive, The Hill reported, which leaves almost no room for the hearings and amendments that a package this size deserves.

That does not mean the president is wrong about the need. Rebuilding munitions and preparing for threats from Iran and China is urgent work. The question is how to pay for it and how to pass it in a way that lasts.

What Comes Next

Watch for two things over the next three weeks: whether negotiators can grow the $69 billion in the bipartisan bill closer to the president's request, and whether Thune revives the reconciliation path if talks stall. Either way, the Dec. 11 deadline will force a decision before Christmas.

Sources

  1. The Washington Post: Republicans break with Trump on his request for a party-line Pentagon funding bill (link)
  2. Reuters via SRN News: Congress struggles to avert US shutdown as Iran war divides lawmakers (link)
  3. The Hill: Thune fears GOP revolt over Medicaid cuts in Pentagon funding push (link)
  4. The Hill: Thune aiming for decision in next 24 hours on budget reconciliation push to fund Pentagon (link)
  5. Breaking Defense: Senate appropriators unveil $1.1T Pentagon spending bill, folding in reconciliation priorities (link)
  6. The Hill: GOP senators warn Trump push for Pentagon funding risks shutdown (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pagePoliticsTurn the pageWater for the Valley, Light on the Files: What Lauren…