Politics
No New GOP Defectors: Kaine's Iran War Powers Resolution Fails 48-51 in the First Post-Election Vote
Collins, Murkowski and Paul again sided with Democrats, Fetterman sided with Republicans, and the House-passed measure picked up no new GOP votes after the election.
By AVA STERLINGStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 19, 6:39 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
The Senate on Thursday rejected the first attempt since this month's midterm elections to force an end to the war with Iran, voting 48-51 against a House-passed resolution, CBS News reported. It was the first time either chamber had voted on the war since the election, and Senate Republicans held together, the Associated Press reported.
The Washington Times reported that the measure picked up no new Republican support despite the party's losses at the polls. Three Republicans, Sens. Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky, voted with Democrats, as they had on similar resolutions before the election. Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania was the lone Democrat to vote with Republicans to block it.
The Senate has taken up war powers challenges on Iran many times since the United States and Israel began striking Iran at the end of February.
What Was on the Table
The measure was a concurrent resolution that had already cleared the House. That means it would not have gone to President Trump for his signature even if the Senate had approved it, according to CBS News. Stars and Stripes described Thursday's vote as the Senate's first post-election attempt to end the war.
That procedural detail tells readers what the vote really was: a statement of position, not a law. Under the Constitution, a measure binds the executive branch only when both chambers pass it and it is presented to the president to sign or veto. A concurrent resolution skips that last step by design.
Sen. Tim Kaine of Virginia, who has led Democrats' repeated efforts to restrict the president's war powers on Iran, pressed Republican colleagues to support the measure before the vote. After it failed, Kaine, Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer and Sen. Adam Schiff of California issued a joint statement accusing the chamber of failing in its duty to serve as a check on the executive.
Why the Line Held
Democrats had hoped the election results would shake loose Republican votes. They did not. The same three Republicans who have broken with the president on the war before remain the only ones willing to do so.
Fetterman's vote is a reminder that the case for standing firm against Iran still has supporters across the aisle. For the senators who voted no, the argument has been consistent: the middle of a war is not the moment to tie the commander in chief's hands, least of all with a resolution that could not become law.
That is not the same as saying Congress has no role. The Constitution gives Congress the power to declare war and the power of the purse, and Kaine and his allies are right that lawmakers should own their votes on a conflict of this size. The question is whether a symbolic resolution is the way to do it. The more honest test is the spending bill, where every member has to say yes or no to paying for the mission and the troops carrying it out.
What Comes Next
That test is coming. Democrats are debating how to use next month's government funding deadline to cut off money for the war without triggering a shutdown, The Washington Times reported.
When the new Congress convenes in January, Democrats will hold the House after this month's election. That gives them far more say over war funding than a resolution in a Republican Senate ever could, and it will force both parties to put their positions into the bills that actually keep the government open.
For now, the Senate's answer is unchanged. The president keeps the authority he has been using, the war goes on, and the real fight moves to the spending bills that will decide how, and for how long, the United States pays for it. Americans who want this war brought to a close on terms that keep the country safe should watch that vote far more closely than Thursday's.
Sources
- CBS News: Iran war powers measure again falls short in Senate (link)
- Associated Press (via WDIV): Senate Republicans block latest Democratic effort to end the war in Iran (link)
- The Washington Times: Senate rejects resolution to end Iran war, with no new GOP support after election rout (link)
- Stars and Stripes: Senate rejects first post-election attempt to end Iran war (link)
- Office of Sen. Tim Kaine: Kaine, Schumer and Schiff slam blocking of Iran war powers resolution (link)
- The Washington Times: Democrats debate how to block Iran war funding without causing government shutdown (link)
— 30 —


