‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Politics

Mercy for the Hit King: Why Trump's Pete Rose Pardon Is a Win for Second Chances

Some coverage dismissed the pardon of baseball's all-time hits leader as a gesture for a disgraced star. Our anchors make the case that it is a promise kept, squarely within the Constitution, and a lesson in grace.

By AVA STERLINGStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 19, 8:22 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic scene of an empty classic American ballpark at golden hour: a single wooden bat leaning against a dugout rail beside a worn leather glove and a scuffed baseball, an American flag rippling above the…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

President Trump's posthumous pardon of Pete Rose drew a cool reception in parts of the press. The Washington Post called Rose a "disgraced MLB star" and suggested the pardon likely won't help his Hall of Fame case. Here is how our anchors answer it.

Ava Sterling, Congress

Pardons are about to become a hot topic on Capitol Hill. Newsweek paired the Rose news with remarks from Rep. Robert Garcia, who is in line to lead the House Oversight Committee, calling President Biden's pardons a "mistake". That contrast is worth holding onto. The Rose pardon frees no prisoner, shields no political ally and spares no one a trial. Rose finished his federal sentence more than three decades ago, and he has been gone since 2024. If the incoming House majority wants to examine how presidents use mercy, this is the easiest case it will ever review: a symbolic act that costs taxpayers nothing and asks nothing in return.

Claire Donovan, the President, the White House

The President announced his "Complete and Total Pardon" on Truth Social on Thursday, The Hill reported, closing out an idea he had been floating for nearly two years. He called Rose a true superstar and legend and said his hits record will never be broken. This is the President being who he has always been: loyal to the working men and women who fill the bleachers, and impatient with institutions that hold grudges long after a debt is paid. Rose grew up and starred in Cincinnati, a blue-collar baseball town that never stopped claiming him. The President did not have to spend a minute of a busy week on a man who can no longer thank him. He did it anyway.

Sophia Reyes, elections, polling

Voters judge leaders on a simple test: did you do what you said you would do? The President floated this pardon nearly two years ago, and on Thursday he delivered. Small promises kept build the trust that big ones depend on. Now the vote that matters belongs to someone else. Because Rose was reinstated too late for the writers' ballot, his case goes to the Hall's Classic Baseball Era Committee, which next meets in December 2027. He would need 12 of its 16 votes, and the earliest he could be inducted is 2028. The pardon does not cast a ballot. It simply reminds the voters in that room that the country is watching.

Lauren Pierce, Supreme Court, DOJ

Article II of the Constitution gives the President the power to grant pardons for offenses against the United States, except in cases of impeachment. Rose's federal offense is clear on the record: in 1990 he pleaded guilty to two counts of filing false income tax returns and served five months in federal prison. The Associated Press noted it was not immediately clear what the pardon would cover, but that tax case is his only criminal conviction, which puts it squarely inside the President's authority. Since the Civil War era, in Ex parte Garland, the Supreme Court has read the pardon power broadly, limited only by the impeachment exception the framers wrote down. Nothing about this pardon tests those limits.

Harold Whitmore, court cases explained

It helps to separate Rose's two punishments. The first was criminal: the 1990 tax case, which he served. The second was baseball's own: the lifetime ban imposed in 1989 after the league concluded he had bet on games as Reds manager. That second penalty is already gone. In May 2025, Commissioner Rob Manfred ruled that permanent ineligibility ends when the person dies, and he removed Rose from the banned list. So the pardon reaches the one penalty only a President can touch. Critics are right that the Hall of Fame makes its own decision. But clearing a criminal record was always the pardon's job, and now it is done.

Benjamin Stone, the Constitution, big debates

Alexander Hamilton argued in Federalist No. 74 that "the benign prerogative of pardoning should be as little as possible fettered." He understood that a republic needs a place for mercy. Rose's greatness is not in dispute: 4,256 hits, more than any player in history, 17 All-Star selections and three World Series titles. Neither are his failings, which he paid for in prison and in decades of exile from the game. The big debate is whether a nation can honor a man's gifts without excusing his sins. Scripture answers that one: mercy triumphs over judgment (James 2:13). Grace is not pretending the wrong never happened. It is deciding the debt has been paid.

The Bottom Line

Pete Rose broke the rules, owned the consequences and spent the rest of his life outside the game he loved. A President who believes in second chances gave him one, too late for Rose to see it, but not too late for the millions of fans who remember how he played.

Sources

  1. The Washington Post: President Trump pardons disgraced MLB star Pete Rose, who died in 2024 (link)
  2. The Hill: Trump posthumously pardons Pete Rose (link)
  3. WALB (Associated Press): Pete Rose posthumously pardoned by Trump after baseball's career hits leader was reinstated by MLB (link)
  4. WTTW News: Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson Reinstated by Major League Baseball, Making Them Hall of Fame Eligible (link)
  5. MLB.com: 10 great moments that defined Rose's career (link)
  6. Newsweek: Trump Pardons Pete Rose as Garcia Calls Biden's Pardons a 'Mistake' (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pagePoliticsTurn the pageCairncross Out as White House Cyber Chief; Pentagon Tech…