‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Politics

Johnson's Warning: Social Security's $511 Billion Hole Is Coming

The Senate Budget chairman's blunt words drew fire, but his report's numbers on the program's 2032 shortfall are the part Americans need to hear.

By DOUGLAS PARKStaff Correspondent · WISCONSIN · Nov 19, 1:34 PM · 2 min. read

Illustration: A weathered Social Security card-style envelope and a stack of retirement benefit letters on a kitchen table beside reading glasses and a cup of coffee, morning light through a window, in the soft-focus background the U.S…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Sen. Ron Johnson, the Wisconsin Republican who chairs the Senate Budget Committee, is taking heat this week for blunt words about Social Security. But the numbers behind his warning have drawn far less attention than the words themselves, and they are the part retirees and workers most need to hear.

Johnson's committee released a report this week warning that Social Security faces a $511 billion shortfall by 2032, American Greatness reported, and the chairman said Americans are being "scammed" by the way Washington has handled the program. Johnson argued that politicians have led Americans to believe the government was setting aside their payroll taxes and investing that money for their own retirement, The Post Millennial reported. The 11-page memo lays out the falling ratio of workers paying into the program compared with those drawing benefits, along with the growing number of years the average recipient collects, according to Just the News.

The remark, and the clarification

What set off the uproar was Johnson's comment that there is no way to fix the program and that it should be shut down, The Hill reported. Democrats rebuked him for suggesting the program be ended, Newsweek reported. Johnson then said his remarks had been "imprecise," according to both outlets.

That clarification matters, and it fits his record. At a Senate Finance hearing in August on a proposal for a Social Security commission, Johnson said he expects Congress would cover the program's deficit from general revenue if it comes to that, and that he wants to preserve Social Security, the Plan Sponsor Council of America reported. He also said he wants to increase support for benefits by cutting federal spending elsewhere, so the program can be paid for without adding to the deficit, according to the same report.

Why the warning deserves a hearing

Calling the program a "Ponzi scheme" is a sharp way to describe a simple fact that Johnson's report documents: today's benefits are paid with today's workers' taxes, and there are fewer workers for every retiree than there used to be. That is not an argument for abandoning the elderly. It is an argument for being honest with them before the money runs short.

Scripture tells families to care for their own, and a nation that promised its seniors a retirement check owes them the truth about whether the promise is funded. A senator who puts the shortfall on the table years before it arrives is doing the work that many in Washington have put off for decades.

What comes next

Democrats have made clear they intend to keep pressing Republicans over Johnson's words. The real test will be whether either party offers a plan to close the gap before 2032 without breaking faith with the Americans who paid in for a lifetime.

Sources

  1. Newsweek: Ron Johnson in Hot Water for Social Security 'Legal Ponzi Scheme' Remark (link)
  2. The Post Millennial: Senator Ron Johnson calls Social Security a 'Legal Ponzi Scheme,' warns of coming $511 BILLION shortfall (link)
  3. The Hill: Ron Johnson: Remark about shutting down Social Security was 'imprecise' (link)
  4. American Greatness: Sen. Ron Johnson Report Warns Social Security Faces $511 Billion Shortfall by 2032 (link)
  5. Just the News: Sen. Ron Johnson blasts Social Security as 'legal Ponzi scheme' (link)
  6. Plan Sponsor Council of America: Senate Finance Debates Social Security Commission Proposal (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageTelling Seniors the Truth: Ron Johnson's Fight to Keep…Turn the pageDOJ Sends L.A. Prosecutor to Probe the Mar-a-Lago Raid