‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Politics

Idaho's Republican Family Feud: Who Speaks for Conservatives?

The GOP still holds a supermajority, but moderates' primary wins and the state party chair's call to define a 'real Republican' have exposed a deep split over how to govern.

By JACK HOLLISTERStaff Correspondent · IDAHO · Nov 20, 8:38 PM · 2 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic view of the Idaho State Capitol dome in Boise at golden hour, white marble and sandstone glowing against a clear sky, an American flag and the Idaho state flag flying side by side, a winding road…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Idaho Republicans kept their supermajority in the Legislature this month, but inside the party the argument over what it means to be a conservative is as heated as ever, the Deseret News reported Friday.

The Fault Line

The divide is over what the Republican Party should stand for in Idaho and who gets to speak for it, according to the Deseret News, which described a contest between the party's harder-right wing and its more moderate members. One flashpoint was a January op-ed by state party chair Dorothy Moon titled "How to Identify a Real Republican". Her critics accuse her of treating only her own wing as true Republicans and of using party rules to punish those who dissent, the paper reported.

What the Voters Did

The May primaries delivered the clearest verdict so far. Boise State Public Radio reported that Idaho's Republican primaries favored more moderate candidates, bucking the national trend, as several members of a hard-line legislative bloc known as the "Gang of Eight" lost their seats. In the Magic Valley around Twin Falls, Idaho Education News counted four incumbents voted out in what it called a major shakeup. The Deseret News reported that centrist Republicans there organized the push that ousted most of the lawmakers who had first won in 2024.

Moon, for her part, has cast November's results as a victory for Idaho values. In a post-election column she wrote that voters again returned a Republican supermajority, and she warned elected officials that they will be expected to keep their promises.

Those who lost in May will not be returning to Boise when lawmakers convene in January.

Hollister's Take

A party that holds a supermajority can afford an argument, and Idaho Republicans are having theirs in the right place: in front of voters, in primaries, out in the open. That is how self-government is supposed to work. Nobody in this fight is proposing to raise taxes, take away guns or walk away from the unborn. From where I sit, the quarrel is over temperament and tactics, over how to govern once you have the votes, not over whether to be conservative.

The risk is not disagreement. The risk is a feud that turns neighbors into enemies and makes the work of governing harder for people who mostly want the same things. Idaho's conservatives have built one of the most successful Republican states in the country. The test now is whether both wings can argue hard, accept what the voters decide, and still pull in the same direction when the session opens in January. Voters in the Magic Valley sent a message about tone, and the party's leaders sent one about principle. Both deserve a fair hearing, and Republicans in other states, sorting out their own differences after this fall's elections, will be watching how Idaho handles it.

Sources

  1. Deseret News: In deep-red Idaho, Republicans battle over the party's future (link)
  2. Boise State Public Radio: Idaho primaries favor moderate Republicans, bucking trend (link)
  3. Idaho Education News: Magic Valley voters oust four incumbents in major shakeup (link)
  4. Gem State Chronicle: Moon: A Victory for Idaho Values, a Warning (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pagePoliticsTurn the pageBack From Asia, Trump Takes 90 Minutes of Questions…