‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Politics

DOJ Drops Its Alaska Certification Suit as the 'Decoy Dan' Probe Rolls On

With Peltola past 50 percent, the Justice Department told the Ninth Circuit its election case is moot, while a criminal investigation into the second Dan Sullivan on the ballot keeps moving.

By LAUREN PIERCEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 20, 12:20 AM · 2 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic scene: a stately federal courthouse entrance at dusk with snow-covered Alaskan mountains rising behind it, an Alaska state flag and an American flag stirring on tall poles, a sealed wooden ballot box…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The Justice Department on Thursday moved to wind down its lawsuit over the certification of Alaska's U.S. Senate race, telling an appeals court the case is now moot because Democrat Mary Peltola won an outright majority over Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan, the Washington Examiner and ABC News reported.

The filing does not end the federal government's interest in how that ballot came together. A separate criminal investigation into the so-called "Decoy Dan" candidacy is continuing, with hundreds of subpoenas issued, Fox News reported.

What the Department Asked For

The department had filed the civil suit before the count was final, seeking to hold up certification if Sullivan lost narrowly, so the courts could weigh whether voters confused by a second Dan Sullivan on the ballot had marked the wrong name, the Washington Examiner reported. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case, finding the federal government lacked standing, and the department took it to the Ninth Circuit, the Alaska Beacon reported.

In Thursday's filing, department lawyers asked the Ninth Circuit to declare the appeal moot now that the result no longer turns on a narrow margin, and to vacate the lower court's dismissal order, according to ABC News and the Alaska Beacon. Vacating that order would keep Gleason's standing ruling from serving as a precedent in future election cases, a common request when a case ends before an appeal is decided.

The Associated Press tally put Peltola at 144,302 votes to Sullivan's 131,844, a gap of about 12,500, Newsweek reported. With her share above 50 percent, no ranked-choice rounds are needed. State election officials have said certification is on track for next week, with Nov. 25 as the target date, the Alaska Beacon reported.

The Criminal Probe Goes On

The legal fight began with a question many Alaskans asked for months: how did a Petersburg man listed as Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., running with no party, end up on the same four-name ballot as the senator? Republicans who tried to remove him lost in the Alaska Supreme Court in June, ABC News 4 reported.

The New York Times reported, in an account relayed by ABC News 4, that Peltola campaign staff and lawyers worked with aides at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee to find candidates for the ballot. The Peltola campaign denied recruiting any spoiler, the DSCC said it had no involvement, and the second Sullivan has said he entered the race on his own.

Federal investigators are not treating the matter as closed. The department has issued about 200 subpoenas and sent more than 20 target and preservation letters, and the inquiry reaches across several states, Fox News reported, citing people familiar with the probe. The department declined to comment to Fox News.

Why It Matters

Dropping a civil case that the vote count has overtaken is what a careful law office does. The department built the suit for a razor-thin loss, the margin turned out to be wide, and it said so in court rather than pressing a claim the numbers no longer support.

The harder question was never only about one race. If a campaign can quietly put a candidate's namesake on the ballot to siphon votes, every voter in America has a stake in the answer. That question now sits with prosecutors, not with the certification calendar. Sullivan's campaign has said it will not concede before the state certifies the result.

Sources

  1. Washington Examiner: DOJ drops lawsuit challenging certification of Alaska Senate race after Peltola wins (link)
  2. ABC News: DOJ dropping Alaska midterms Senate certification lawsuit, saying case is 'moot' (link)
  3. Alaska Beacon: DOJ abandons lawsuit that sought to pause certification of Alaska's US Senate election (link)
  4. Fox News: DOJ issues 200 subpoenas in Alaska 'Decoy Dan' criminal probe: sources (link)
  5. Newsweek: Mary Peltola Wins Alaska Senate Election in Final Democratic Flip (link)
  6. ABC News 4: Democrats, Peltola campaign recruited Dan Sullivan to spoil Senate race for GOP: report (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous page'Food Security Is National Security': Trump Presses…Turn the pageFBI: Patel Was in the Field as His Deputy Testified