Politics
Betting on America in Orbit: Private Investment Is How the U.S. Keeps Its Lead in Space
The left calls a few minority stakes in American space companies a grift. The record shows public deals, small shares, no contract awarded, and an industry the country needs.
By AVA STERLINGStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 19, 2:53 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
This week, critics seized on a Politico report that Donald Trump Jr.'s firm, 1789 Capital, has invested in three of the six companies competing to help replace the International Space Station, and one outlet branded it a "grift". The firm says its stakes are minor and carry no control. Here is how our anchors answer.
Ava Sterling, Congress
Congress holds the purse strings for NASA, and oversight is part of the job. But oversight starts with facts. Rep. Jamie Raskin has questioned how 1789 Capital picks its companies, and the firm has called his remarks unsubstantiated. No contract has been awarded, and a decision could come next year. If members of either party think NASA's process is weak, the answer is to write better rules for the competition, in the open, and then judge the winners on cost, safety and schedule. Smearing investors before a single award is made does nothing for the astronauts who will fly.
Claire Donovan, the White House
Donald Trump Jr. holds no office in his father's administration, and nothing in the reporting shows him playing any part in NASA's decision. What the record does show is a firm taking small positions alongside much bigger backers. Starlab's other investors include Voyager Technologies, Airbus, Mitsubishi and Palantir. Axiom's round was led by Qatar's sovereign wealth fund and Type One Ventures. The administration's goal is plain: an American-built station flying before the old one is retired, so that the United States never has to borrow a seat in orbit from a rival.
Sophia Reyes, Elections and Polling
Democrats are preparing to take the House gavel in January, and stories like this one preview the next two years: a steady drip of insinuation aimed at the President's family. Voters can tell the difference between a finding and a headline. A press release from May announcing the Starlab investment is not a secret, and a minority stake is not a scheme. Republicans should welcome real scrutiny and answer every question with documents. That is how you win back trust, and it is how you win the argument.
Lauren Pierce, the Supreme Court and the Justice Department
Investing in a lawful American business is not a crime, and private citizens do not lose that right because of who their father is. Ethics rules bind the officials who award contracts, and those officials at NASA are the ones to watch. The Supreme Court has also warned against stretching corruption law to cover mere access and influence. In McDonnell v. United States, a unanimous Court held that an "official act" must be specific and focused on a pending matter.
Harold Whitmore, Court Cases Explained
The McDonnell case is worth remembering. A jury convicted a former Virginia governor in a case built on meetings, calls and events he arranged for a donor who had given him gifts and loans. In 2016, all eight justices threw out that reading of the law, holding that setting up meetings or hosting events is not, by itself, an official act. The lesson reaches beyond the courtroom: being near power is not proof of wrongdoing. Accusations need evidence of a specific act, and in this case no one has pointed to one.
Benjamin Stone, the Constitution and Big Debates
NASA's new model makes it a customer, not the owner, of the next generation of stations in low Earth orbit, with the space station due to retire around 2030. That model only works if private capital takes the risk. Shutting investors out because of their politics or their family name would shrink the field and hand the advantage to China. Scripture's wisdom applies here too: Proverbs teaches that the first to argue a case seems right until the other side is heard. Now it has been.
Sources
- Political Wire: Don Jr. Could Profit From Space Station Successor (link)
- The Daily Beast: Don Jr.'s Grift Is Now Literally Out of This World (link)
- Business Wire: Starlab and 1789 Capital Announce Strategic Investment (link)
- CNBC: Axiom Space raises $350 million backed by Donald Trump Jr.'s firm, Qatar fund (link)
- Space.com: NASA working to get private space stations up and running before ISS retires in 2030 (link)
- Justia: McDonnell v. United States, 579 U.S. (2016) (link)
— 30 —


