‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Florida & Southeast News

Following State Law, Miami Moves to Close Its DEI Offices and Pare Back Its LGBTQ Board Ahead of Thursday's First Vote

City commissioners take up an ordinance to comply with Florida's new limits on local diversity programs, which take effect Jan. 1. A second vote would still be required.

By TOMÁS ORTEGAStaff Correspondent · FLORIDA · Nov 18, 3:00 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic view of Miami City Hall, the white Art Deco former Pan Am terminal on Dinner Key, at sunrise with palm trees and sailboats in Biscayne Bay behind it, an American flag and Florida flag on poles out…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The City of Miami is moving to bring its government in line with Florida's new law limiting diversity, equity and inclusion programs in local government. The Miami City Commission is scheduled to vote Thursday, Nov. 20, on an ordinance that would eliminate the city's office of equal opportunity, repeal its affirmative action policy and sharply scale back its LGBTQ Advisory Board, Axios Miami reported.

The city is acting to comply with Senate Bill 1134, which takes effect Jan. 1 and bars local governments from funding or supporting DEI efforts, according to Axios. Thursday's vote is only a first reading; the ordinance would need a second vote to become final, the Key West Citizen reported.

What the ordinance would do

Under the proposal, the LGBTQ Advisory Board would lose 12 of its 13 duties and its designated city attorney, remaining as a body of volunteers with basic administrative support, according to the Key West Citizen. The ordinance also targets the city's Equal Opportunity Advisory Board and its Equal Opportunity and Diversity Programs office.

Under that description, the board would continue to exist in a reduced form. But its formal role in city policy would be largely removed, in keeping with the state's direction that local governments step back from identity-based programs.

What the state law requires

Gov. Ron DeSantis signed SB 1134 in April, the Florida Phoenix reported. The law prohibits local governments from funding, promoting or implementing DEI initiatives and bars them from keeping DEI offices, officers or programs. Contractors and grant recipients must certify that public money will not be used for prohibited DEI work, according to a summary by the law firm Becker.

The law has teeth. DeSantis said violations can be treated as misfeasance or malfeasance in office, residents can sue local governments they believe are not complying, and officials found in violation can be removed from office, the Florida Phoenix reported. The law still allows local governments to provide antidiscrimination training, WUSF reported.

Where officials stand

Commissioner Damian Pardo has said he plans to vote no, according to the Key West Citizen. Mayor Eileen Higgins does not have a vote on the commission but does hold veto power, and she had not said whether she would use it.

Critics of the state law have warned that it could reach programs that help minority-owned businesses compete for public contracts and efforts to address disparities in public health, WUSF reported. LGBTQ advocacy groups have argued it also reaches local spending on Pride events. A Miami Herald report carried by Yahoo described the Miami proposal as part of the state law's widening reach, from city boards to holiday parades.

The case for the change

Supporters see the law in simpler terms: equal treatment. Every resident of Miami, of every background, pays the same taxes and deserves the same treatment from City Hall. Government offices organized around group identity, they argue, divide residents into categories rather than serving them as equal citizens. The state's answer is to keep antidiscrimination protections in place while ending taxpayer-funded programs that sort people by group.

There is also the plain matter of the law. Florida's Legislature passed SB 1134, the governor signed it, and it takes effect in weeks. City leaders have a duty to follow state law, and the ordinance before the commission is designed to do exactly that. Other Florida communities have faced the same choice; in Delray Beach, questions about the law's reach touched off a debate over the city's St. Patrick's Day parade earlier this month.

What comes next

If commissioners approve the ordinance on first reading Thursday, it will come back for a second vote before it can take effect. The state law's Jan. 1 start date leaves the city little time. We will report the outcome of Thursday's vote and any decision by the mayor on a veto.

Sources

  1. Axios Miami: Miami could gut DEI initiatives to comply with state law (link)
  2. Key West Citizen: Miami moves to gut LGBTQ board, repeal DEI programs (link)
  3. Yahoo News: From Miami's LGBTQ+ board to an Irish parade, Florida's anti-DEI law spreads its reach (link)
  4. Florida Phoenix: DeSantis signs law blocking local governments from funding DEI (link)
  5. WUSF: Florida cities and counties face new limits after DeSantis signs DEI, climate bills (link)
  6. Becker: Governor Ron DeSantis Signs Florida CS/CS/SB 1134 (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageA Foot of Rain Overnight: Broward Closes Its Schools as…Turn the pageFive Checked for Injuries After Severe Turbulence Rocks a…