‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Faith & Religion

The Ten Commandments Stay on Texas Classroom Walls for Now, as Paxton Warns the Supreme Court His Successor Won't Defend the Law

A 9-8 appeals court ruling lets Texas enforce Senate Bill 10, but a Democratic attorney general takes office in January and Democrats have filed a repeal bill. Supporters are watching schools for compliance.

By MARGARET CALLAHANStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 18, 9:30 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: A sunlit Texas public school classroom in the morning, rows of wooden desks, a framed poster of two arched stone tablets with blank surfaces and no readable writing hanging on the wall between an American flag and a Texas…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

For now, the Ten Commandments are still on the wall in Texas public school classrooms. But this month's Democratic wave has put the future of the state's landmark law in doubt, ABC News reported, raising new questions about who will defend it in court and whether lawmakers will try to tear it down.

The law, known as Senate Bill 10, requires a copy of the Ten Commandments to be displayed in every public school classroom in Texas. In April, the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled 9 to 8 that the state may enforce it, JURIST reported. Families who oppose the law have asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take up the case, and the justices have not yet said whether they will.

A brief with an unusual warning

Outgoing Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has now told the high court it should not take the case right now, Baptist News Global reported. His reason is striking. The state's brief says the incoming attorney general, Democrat Nathan Johnson, who takes office in January, has said publicly that he will not defend the law. In other words, if the justices agree to hear the case, Texas could arrive at the Supreme Court with no one willing to argue for a law its own legislature passed.

That is a real problem, and not only for Texans who support the law. When an elected official refuses to defend a statute the people's representatives enacted, he turns his personal view of the Constitution into a veto the voters never gave him. The proper place to change a law is the legislature, and Texas has one.

What the appeals court decided

The Fifth Circuit's majority took the Constitution's history seriously. JURIST reported that the court relied on the historical-practices test the Supreme Court adopted in Kennedy v. Bremerton, the 2022 decision that protected a high school football coach's right to pray on the field. The majority found no coercion, because students are not required to read, recite or follow the Commandments, and they face no penalty for rejecting them.

Critics point to Stone v. Graham, a 1980 Supreme Court decision that struck down a Kentucky law requiring the Commandments in classrooms. The Fifth Circuit's majority distinguished that case and applied the modern Court's history-based approach instead. The families challenging the law, represented by the ACLU and allied groups, argue the opposite and want the justices to settle the question.

The Ten Commandments are not a stranger to American public life. They are among the oldest written foundations of moral law in the Western world, and generations of Americans learned right from wrong from them. Posting them on a classroom wall does not force anyone to believe. It reminds children of the moral tradition that shaped the country they live in.

The fight moves to Austin

The legal fight now has a political front. Democrats have filed a bill to repeal the Ten Commandments requirement ahead of the 2027 legislative session. The session opens January 12 and runs through May 31, KXAN reported.

Supporters are not standing still. Texas Values, a faith-based policy group, warned on November 10 that the law still stands and that schools must still comply, and it has asked supporters to help monitor whether their local schools are following it, Baptist News Global reported. That kind of citizen involvement is exactly how self-government is supposed to work: parents and neighbors paying attention to what happens in their children's schools.

What comes next

Watch three things. First, whether the Supreme Court agrees to hear the case before the new attorney general takes office. Second, whether the repeal bill gains traction when the legislature convenes in January. Third, whether school districts keep the displays up while the fight continues. For now, the law of Texas is clear, and the Commandments stay on the wall. Texans who want them to remain there will need to make their voices heard in Austin.

Sources

  1. ABC News: Democratic wave upends battle over Ten Commandments in Texas classrooms (link)
  2. Baptist News Global: Paxton says high court shouldn't consider Ten Commandments case now (link)
  3. Baptist News Global: Texas Values tracks schools' compliance with Ten Commandments law (link)
  4. JURIST: US appeals court rules Texas can require Ten Commandments in classrooms (link)
  5. ACLU: Texas Families Urge U.S. Supreme Court to Take Case on Texas Law Requiring Ten Commandments in Public School Classrooms (link)
  6. KXAN: Texas legislators to pre-file bills ahead of 2027 session (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pagePew: Islam on Track to Pass Christianity as the World's…Turn the pageFour Hundred Years Over the Tomb of the Apostle: Pope Leo…