‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Elections

Texas Rolls the Dice, Literally, on Its First Statewide Election Audit, Starting With the Talarico-Paxton Senate Race

A risk-limiting audit required by the 2021 election reforms will check the reported result against randomly drawn paper ballots. Experts expect it to confirm Talarico's 1.2-million-vote win, and that is the point.

By SOPHIA REYESStaff Correspondent · TEXAS · Nov 20, 2:03 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic image of a quiet election office in Texas, neat stacks of paper ballots in clear sealed boxes on a long wooden table, a set of ten-sided dice resting on a ledger in the foreground under warm light, a…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Texas has begun the first statewide risk-limiting audit in its history, and the first race under the microscope is the U.S. Senate contest that Democrat James Talarico won over Republican Ken Paxton earlier this month, Houston Public Media reported.

The audit is required by state law, not by a candidate or a party, and election officials stress that it is a routine check on whether the reported winner actually won, Newsweek reported. Its result, whatever it shows, will be a test of a set of election reforms Texas Republicans wrote into law five years ago.

What the Audit Does

A risk-limiting audit is a statistical check of an election's outcome. Instead of recounting every ballot, auditors pull a random sample of paper ballots and compare what is marked on them to what the machines recorded. If the sample matches the reported result closely enough, the audit confirms the outcome. If it does not, auditors keep pulling more ballots, up to a full hand count if needed. The method uses randomly selected paper ballots to independently verify the result, Houston Public Media reported.

To make sure no one could predict which ballots would be chosen, the secretary of state's office rolled a series of 10-sided dice to generate the random number that drives the selection, according to Houston Public Media and the secretary of state's announcement. The office said it was starting two audits of the Nov. 3 election as prescribed by law.

Counties are also running their own sample hand counts. In Cameron County, for example, election officials are reviewing three races: the U.S. Senate race, the race for chief justice of the Texas Supreme Court and one locally selected contest, KRGV reported.

Why Texas Is Doing This Now

The audit grows out of two election laws passed in 2021, Senate Bill 1 and Senate Bill 598, which set a five-year timeline for putting risk-limiting audits in place, Houston Public Media reported. This year's election is the first in which the audit is being carried out statewide, and the Victoria Advocate described it as the first statewide audit of election results in Texas.

Those laws were among the most debated in the country when Texas Republicans passed them. Critics at the time called them unnecessary. Supporters said that clear rules, paper ballots and independent checks would give every voter, of every party, more reason to trust the count.

The Race Being Audited

Talarico beat Paxton by nearly 1.2 million votes, out of about 10 million ballots cast, according to figures on the secretary of state's website cited by Houston Public Media. That is a wide margin, and election law experts do not expect the audit to change it. Election law attorney Cris Feldman said he does not expect the review to change the outcome of the Senate race, Houston Public Media reported.

Newsweek framed the audit as coming after the Democratic sweep in this month's midterms. But the timing is a matter of law, not politics: the five-year schedule set in 2021 happened to land on this election.

Why This Is Good News for Everyone

Conservatives have spent years making the case that election integrity is not about any one candidate. It is about a process every American can trust, win or lose. Texas is now proving that point in the most convincing way possible: by carefully auditing a statewide race that a Republican lost.

If the audit confirms Talarico's win, as experts expect, Texas Democrats will have the strongest possible proof that their victory was clean. If it found a problem, every Texan would want to know. Either way, the voters win. That is exactly what the 2021 reforms were built to do.

Other states are watching. Risk-limiting audits are relatively cheap, quick and based on paper ballots that voters marked themselves. They do not depend on trusting a machine, a party or a single official. A state that can show its work, ballot by ballot, gives its citizens a reason to accept the result even when their candidate falls short.

For a country that has gone through years of bitter fights over who really won, that kind of confidence is worth more than any single race.

Sources

  1. Newsweek: Texas Launches Audit of Senate Race Results after Democratic Sweep (link)
  2. Texas Secretary of State: Texas Secretary of State Initiates Two Audits of the Nov. 3 Election as Prescribed by Law (link)
  3. Houston Public Media: Texas Secretary of State launches first-of-its-kind audit of U.S. Senate election, newly required by state law (link)
  4. Victoria Advocate: Texas launches first statewide audit of election results (link)
  5. KRGV: Cameron County Elections Department to review three races as part of first statewide audit (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageElectionsTurn the pageRubio Jumps Ahead of Vance in First Post-Midterm 2028 Poll