‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Education

Two Years After a Promise, Washington Opens a New Civil Rights Review of Antisemitism in Philadelphia's Schools

The Education Department says the district has not kept the commitments it made in 2024 to protect Jewish students. District officials say they were given no warning.

By ETHAN CALLOWAYStaff Correspondent · PENNSYLVANIA · Nov 19, 11:31 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic early-morning scene of a classic red-brick Philadelphia public school building with tall arched windows, stone steps scattered with autumn leaves and a flagpole flying the American flag, Philadelphia rowhouses…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The U.S. Department of Education has opened a new civil rights review of the School District of Philadelphia, saying the district has not lived up to the promises it made two years ago to protect Jewish students from harassment. The department's Office for Civil Rights announced the review on Monday, making it the third federal look at the city's schools since 2024, Chalkbeat Philadelphia reported.

The new review centers on a settlement the district entered into voluntarily in 2024. Federal officials say the district has failed to meet its obligations under that agreement, JNS reported. The Washington Stand, a publication of the Family Research Council, described the move as the department's latest effort to combat antisemitism in Philadelphia's public schools.

Why Washington Is Back

In its announcement, the Office for Civil Rights pointed to a recent investigation by the U.S. House Education and Workforce Committee as evidence that antisemitism in the district has worsened since the 2024 agreement, according to Chalkbeat. The department did not spell out what the new review will include.

The House committee's work put a national spotlight on Philadelphia this fall. Superintendent Tony B. Watlington Sr. was called to testify before the committee, and he told lawmakers the district planned to change its social studies curriculum in partnership with national experts, Chalkbeat reported.

What Happened in 2024

The current review grows out of an earlier federal investigation. In December 2024, the Office for Civil Rights found that the district had failed to respond properly to reports of antisemitic harassment, WHYY reported. Federal investigators found the district did not show it had assessed whether the incidents created a hostile environment for Jewish students, according to Chalkbeat's account of the resolution.

To settle that case, the district agreed to make changes. It signed a one-year resolution agreement without admitting fault, Chalkbeat reported. The Anti-Defamation League, which had filed one of the complaints that led to the investigation, welcomed that resolution at the time.

Now federal officials say those changes did not stick, and that Jewish students are still not getting the protection the law requires.

The District Pushes Back

Philadelphia school officials are not accepting the federal account quietly. District officials said they have tried to keep the Office for Civil Rights informed of their work to combat antisemitism, and that they were given no advance notice before the department announced the new review, Chalkbeat reported. They also said they were disappointed by the decision.

That is a fair point to hear out. Any school district deserves the chance to show its work, and federal reviews should be about results, not headlines. But the district's response leaves the central question unanswered: are Jewish children in Philadelphia's public schools safe, welcome and treated equally today? Two years after a signed agreement, families should not have to wonder.

Why It Matters to Every Parent

Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 bars discrimination based on race, color or national origin in any program that receives federal money, and federal officials have long applied it to harassment of Jewish students based on shared ancestry. The law does not make exceptions for popular causes or campus politics. A child who is harassed for being Jewish is owed the same swift response as any other child who is targeted for who he is.

For people of faith, that principle runs deeper than any statute. Schools that tolerate hatred against one group teach every student that bigotry is acceptable if it is aimed at the right target. Parents of every background, Christian and Jewish alike, have a stake in making sure that lesson is never taught in an American classroom.

Philadelphia is a city with a long and proud Jewish history, and its public schools serve students of every faith. Getting this right is not a partisan project. It is the minimum the district owes the families who trust it with their children every day.

What Comes Next

The Office for Civil Rights has not said how long its review will take. If investigators find the district broke its 2024 promises, the department can demand new corrective steps, and federal law allows it to seek to cut off funding from districts that refuse to comply, though that remedy is rarely used.

In the meantime, the district says it is continuing its work, including the curriculum changes Watlington described to Congress. Parents, teachers and lawmakers will be watching to see whether those changes produce what matters most: classrooms where every child, of every faith, can learn without fear.

Sources

  1. Chalkbeat Philadelphia: Trump administration launches probe into alleged antisemitism in Philadelphia schools (link)
  2. JNS: Ed Department investigates Philadelphia School District over alleged violations of 2024 Jew-hatred agreement (link)
  3. The Washington Stand: Dept of Ed. Seeks to Combat Anti-Semitism in Philadelphia Schools (link)
  4. Chalkbeat Philadelphia: After feds find poor response to antisemitic incidents, Philadelphia district agrees to changes (link)
  5. WHYY: U.S. civil rights probe faults Philadelphia School District over handling of antisemitism reports (link)
  6. Anti-Defamation League: ADL welcomes resolution of its complaint against School District of Philadelphia (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageThe Speech Went On: Chloe Cole Takes the Stage at the…Turn the pageAlbemarle County Closes Every School Through Thanksgiving…