‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Crime & Justice

Unanimous Again: Parole Board Keeps Susan Smith Behind Bars

Thirty-two years after she drowned her two young sons in a South Carolina lake, the board again said no.

By ELIJAH CARTERStaff Correspondent · CALIFORNIA · Nov 19, 1:35 PM · 2 min. read

Illustration: A quiet South Carolina lake at dawn under a soft pink and gray sky, morning mist over still water, a small white memorial cross with two tiny bouquets of wildflowers on the grassy bank, tall Carolina pines along the shore, a…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

South Carolina's parole board on Thursday unanimously turned down Susan Smith's bid for freedom for a second time, 32 years after she murdered her two young sons, Newsweek and NBC News reported. The decision keeps behind bars a woman whose crime shocked the nation in 1994 and remains one of the most painful child-murder cases in modern American memory.

Smith, now 55, is serving a life sentence for the 1994 drownings of 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex, the Los Angeles Times reported. She killed the boys by letting her car roll into a South Carolina lake with them strapped inside. The jury that convicted her chose not to impose the death penalty, leaving her eligible to seek parole decades later.

The hearing

To win release, Smith needed the support of two-thirds of the seven-member board, and she did not get a single vote, according to WSOC and CNN. She appeared by video from prison and apologized to her former husband and to the community, NBC News and CNN reported. Her defense told the board about her struggles with depression and mental illness, while prosecutors argued that she killed her sons because she wanted a new life with another man, a claim she disputed. Her next chance at parole will come in 2028, the reports said.

The boys' father, David Smith, urged the board not to release her and afterward thanked its members for keeping her in prison for at least two more years, WSOC and Oxygen reported. Before the hearing he had said he wants his former wife to remain in prison until she dies. For him, every parole date reopens a wound that never fully closed.

Why the case still matters

In 1994, Smith first told investigators that a stranger had taken her car with her children inside, setting off a nationwide search before she confessed days later. The lie and the loss left a lasting mark on the town of Union and on a country that had hoped the boys would be found safe.

Justice for children who cannot speak for themselves is not a matter of revenge. It is a matter of taking innocent life as seriously as the law says we must. A sentence of life in prison means something only if it is honored, and Thursday's unanimous vote honored it. Mercy has its place, and Smith can seek it from God. But the state's first duty is to the two little boys whose lives were taken and to the family that still grieves them.

What comes next

Smith remains in state prison. The boys' father has left no doubt that he will keep opposing any effort to set her free when her case comes up again in 2028.

Sources

  1. Newsweek: Susan Smith Denied Parole Decades After Drowning Murders of 2 Young Sons (link)
  2. NBC News: Susan Smith is denied parole again 32 years after drowning her sons in a South Carolina lake (link)
  3. WSOC TV: Susan Smith denied parole for second time in 2 years (link)
  4. CNN: Susan Smith, who killed her young boys 3 decades ago in a South Carolina lake, is denied parole (link)
  5. Los Angeles Times: Susan Smith asks for parole again 32 years after drowning her sons in a South Carolina lake (link)
  6. Oxygen: Susan Smith's Bid For Parole is Denied 32 Years After She Drowned Sons in a Lake (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageFCC Clears State Prisons to Jam Smuggled Cellphones After…Turn the pageGrand Jury Indicts Illinois Man on Terrorism Charges in…