‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Crime & Justice

No Charges for Madison Officer in Corey Ruiz Shooting as DA Cites a Knife and Failed Tasers

Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne found that Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson acted reasonably in the July 22 struggle. Ruiz's family and attorney Ben Crump condemned the decision.

By ELIJAH CARTERStaff Correspondent · CALIFORNIA · Nov 19, 10:24 PM · 2 min. read

Illustration: The Wisconsin State Capitol dome in Madison glowing at dusk, seen down a quiet tree-lined street with wet pavement reflecting streetlights, a parked police cruiser with its lights dark at the curb, fallen autumn leaves…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

A Madison, Wisconsin, police officer who shot and killed a 38-year-old man during a struggle in July will not face criminal charges, Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne announced Thursday.

Ozanne concluded that Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson acted reasonably when he used deadly force against Corey Ruiz on July 22, after Ruiz resisted officers, produced a knife and was not stopped by repeated Taser attempts, according to reports from The Associated Press and the New York Post. The decision brought immediate calls for justice from Ruiz's relatives and community advocates.

What the prosecutor weighed

Baitinger-Peterson, who has more than a decade of law enforcement experience, was one of four officers who responded to calls about someone checking out parked cars, the Los Angeles Times reported. Ozanne's review drew on police reports, scene diagrams and video from squad cars, surveillance cameras and bystanders, according to the AP's account.

Two other officers fired Tasers at Ruiz moments before the shooting, and Baitinger-Peterson told investigators he had grabbed Ruiz's arm before he realized Ruiz was holding a knife, the AP reported. Ruiz was shot twice after he went to the ground. Madison officers do not wear body cameras, so no body-camera recording of the encounter exists.

In the days after the shooting, police said Ruiz had fled on a bicycle and that a fixed-blade knife injured an officer in the struggle that followed. The Wisconsin Department of Justice's Division of Criminal Investigation investigated the shooting, and Ozanne said from the start that the charging decision would rest with his office under state law.

Family and police respond

Ruiz's family and their attorney, Ben Crump, condemned the decision, and Crump said the video showed no justification for the shooting. In July, Crump said bystander video appeared to show Ruiz being tased and taken to the ground before the officer fired, and he pressed for criminal charges.

The Wisconsin Professional Police Association backed Ozanne's findings. Baitinger-Peterson and the three other officers who dealt with Ruiz have been on paid administrative leave since the shooting.

The question at the heart of the case

Every police use-of-force case turns on the same question: whether an officer facing an armed, resisting suspect acted reasonably in the seconds he had to decide. After four months of work by state investigators, the county's elected prosecutor answered yes. That conclusion deserves respect, and so does the grief of a mother who lost her son.

The reports did not indicate any further criminal review. It was not immediately clear whether Ruiz's family, represented by Crump since July, would turn to the civil courts.

Madison officers will keep answering calls on the same streets where this confrontation unfolded, and residents will keep asking how such encounters can end without a life lost. Prayer for the Ruiz family, and for the officers who take calls like this one every night, is a fitting place for the whole city to start.

Sources

  1. The Washington Times: Prosecutor declines to charge a Madison, Wisconsin, police officer who fatally shot a Black man (link)
  2. Los Angeles Times: Prosecutor declines to charge a police officer who fatally shot a Black man in Wisconsin (link)
  3. New York Post: Wisconsin police officer who fatally shot ex-con will not be charged, prosecutor says (link)
  4. FOX 11: Dane County district attorney releases statement on fatal police shooting (link)
  5. FOX6 News: Madison police shooting: Corey Ruiz identified as man killed (link)
  6. TMJ4: Family of Corey Ruiz retains civil rights attorney Ben Crump after deadly Madison police shooting (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageFather Kills Wife, Three Young Children and Himself in…Turn the pageFull Appeals Court Won't Rehear Rep. McIver's Bid to Toss…