‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Crime & Justice

Justice on American Soil: Indian National Gets Nearly 20 Years for Plot to Assassinate a Sikh Activist in New York

Nikhil Gupta, who admitted his role in the foiled 2023 murder-for-hire scheme against U.S. citizen Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, is sentenced to 235 months as the former Indian official accused of directing it remains at large.

By NATALIE SINCLAIRStaff Correspondent · NEW YORK · Nov 20, 2:15 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic view of the granite columns and steps of a federal courthouse in Lower Manhattan at early morning, American flag on a tall pole catching the first light, a wooden judge's gavel resting on a sound…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

A federal judge in Manhattan on Friday sentenced Nikhil Gupta, the Indian national who admitted his role in a plot to assassinate a Sikh activist on American soil, to 235 months in prison, or 19 years and seven months. U.S. District Judge Victor Marrero handed down the sentence months after Gupta pleaded guilty, closing one chapter in a case that stretched from New York to Prague to New Delhi.

The target of the foiled 2023 plot was Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, a New York-based lawyer and a leader of the movement for a separate Sikh homeland, whom the BBC described as a U.S.-based Sikh separatist leader. Pannun is an American citizen, and federal prosecutors framed the case as an attack on the safety of a citizen at home.

What Gupta admitted

Gupta, 55, pleaded guilty in February to murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire and conspiracy to commit money laundering, The Hindu reported. Prosecutors say he was recruited in May 2023 by Vikash Yadav, a former Indian intelligence official, to arrange the killing. Yadav has been charged in the case and remains at large, according to the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York.

The plan never got close to succeeding. According to the charges first made public in 2023, the man Gupta believed was a hired killer was in fact working with U.S. law enforcement, and Gupta agreed to a $100,000 price for the killing. He was arrested in the Czech Republic in June 2023 and extradited to the United States in June 2024 to face trial in New York, NBC News reported.

In court on Friday, Gupta apologized to the communities he had hurt, CBS News reported. Pannun attended the hearing, according to reports, and has urged U.S. authorities to go after the people he believes ordered the plot, not just the man who carried out the arrangements.

A sentence at the bottom of the range

The sentence sits at the low end of the advisory guidelines range of 235 to 293 months cited in court filings, but it is far longer than the 12 years Gupta's defense lawyers had requested, The Hindu reported. The defense had pointed to Gupta's age, his lack of a prior record and his acceptance of responsibility, according to reports of the hearing.

U.S. Attorney Jamie McDonald said the prison term reflects the seriousness of Gupta's conduct and warned that the government will pursue anyone who tries to carry out violence on American soil, according to his office's announcement. That is exactly the message the case needed to send. A country that cannot protect its own citizens from contract killers sent by foreign operatives is not a country that controls its own borders or its own streets.

India denies a role

India's government has denied any involvement in the plot, the BBC reported. The case has nonetheless strained relations between Washington and New Delhi. Prosecutors have laid out their account of Yadav's role in public court filings, and it will be up to an American jury, if he is ever brought to the United States, to weigh it.

For Americans, the details matter less than the principle. Whatever one thinks of Pannun's separatist politics, which India's government strongly opposes, his right to speak, organize and live safely in the United States is protected by the same Constitution that protects every other citizen. Free speech means nothing if a foreign government can answer it with a hired gun.

What comes next

With Gupta sentenced, the larger question is Yadav, who prosecutors say directed the scheme and who has not been brought before an American court.

The guilty plea and Friday's sentence show what patient police work can accomplish: an undercover operation that stopped a killing before it happened, an arrest overseas, an extradition, and a conviction in an American courtroom. Federal investigators and prosecutors deserve credit for protecting a citizen and for reminding the world that the United States will not be a hunting ground for anyone's enemies.

Sources

  1. CBS News: Man who plotted to assassinate Sikh political dissident in NYC is sentenced to more than 19 years in prison (link)
  2. U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York: Indian National Sentenced To 235 Months In Prison For Plotting To Assassinate U.S. Citizen In New York (link)
  3. BBC News: Indian man sentenced to 19-plus years in plot to assassinate US-based Sikh separatist leader (link)
  4. Courthouse News: Indian man sentenced to 19 years over plot to assassinate Sikh separatist leader (link)
  5. The Hindu: U.S. court sentences Indian national Nikhil Gupta to 235 months in jail in Pannun murder plot (link)
  6. NBC News: Indian national extradited to U.S. to stand trial in plot to kill Sikh activist in New York (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

DeSantis Weighs 2028 Timing, Says No Decision Yet

In a long interview, Florida's term-limited governor talked through when a White House run might happen, then said he is done discussing it. His record in the state that held for Republicans is the case he would make.

By TOMÁS ORTEGAFlorida & Southeast News · Nov 20, 2:54 PM

One Minute on the Stairs Blunted Sugar Spikes 40%

A San Diego State study found a single minute of stair climbing after a sugary drink sharply lowered blood sugar peaks in healthy adults. The researchers say it is a helpful habit, not a replacement for exercise.

By MICHAEL GRANTHealth & Medicine · Nov 20, 2:49 PM

Previous pageCrime & JusticeTurn the pageThirty Years After a Houston Jeweler Was Killed, Texas…